Repair or Replace Drywall? Expert Guide from Mr. Handyman

In today’s blog post, Mr. Handyman—a professional home improvement contractor—explains when you should consider repairing your drywall and when drywall replacement is a viable option. Mr. Handyman is a top-rated contractor that specializes in drywall repair and replacement. We are one phone call away when you need help with fixing damaged drywall.

Cracks

Cracks in drywall are usually the result of minor structural movement or seasonal shifts in temperature and humidity. Small hairline cracks are cosmetic and can be repaired easily with a bit of joint compound and a fresh coat of paint. These are commonly found near windows, doors, or ceiling corners. However, if the crack is wide, reappears after patching, or runs across multiple panels, it could be a sign of more serious foundation or framing issues. In those cases, it’s better to replace the affected section of drywall after inspecting and addressing the root cause. It’s recommended to consult with a local handyman in Sherman, TX for professional recommendations.

Holes

Holes range from tiny nail pops to large punctures caused by accidents or door handles. Small holes (up to ½ inch) are quick and inexpensive to repair using spackling paste or a patch kit. Medium-sized holes (up to 6 inches) require a mesh patch and some joint compound. But if you’re looking at multiple holes, large damage, or hollow wall sections, replacement may be more practical. Replacing a full panel allows for a cleaner finish and better structural integrity, especially when the damage extends into the backing or framing. You should never ignore drywall holes, as the damage can worsen and cost you more money down the road. Reach out to Mr. Handyman for drywall repair if you’ve noticed holes in your drywall.

Dents

Dents are another common issue, usually caused by furniture, doorknobs, or rough handling. Minor dents that don’t break the drywall surface can be sanded and skim-coated with compound. But if the dent includes paper tearing, crumbling, or soft spots, a more serious repair or even a partial replacement might be needed. Repeated dents in the same area can also indicate weak or deteriorating drywall that won’t hold up to future wear. Call a nearby handyman for an inspection if you’ve noticed drywall dents.

In a nutshell, drywall repair makes sense when the damage is localized, cosmetic, and not compromising the strength of the drywall. Replacement is the better choice when damage is widespread, moisture-related, or affecting the structure of the wall. If you’re planning to hang heavy items or renovate the space, a full replacement also ensures a solid base. To be sure if you need drywall repair or replacement, consult with a professional handyman that specializes in drywall services.

Need Drywall Repair? Contact the Team at Mr. Handyman

Mr. Handyman is a professional home improvement contractor that offers professional and cost-effective drywall repair and replacement. Our technicians have the expertise, experience, and advanced tools to repair a wide range of drywall problems, including cracks, holes, dents, water damage, and nail pops. If you’re not sure whether to repair or replace your drywall, our specialists are ready to perform an inspection and provide professional recommendations. Call us today or book an online appointment with our plumbers.